Blog

Is Your Content Good Enough? When to Hire a Content Marketing Agency.

February 18, 2025

Meta Description: Not sure if your content is hitting the mark? Learn how to evaluate your content marketing and decide if it’s time to hire a professional agency. Here’s how to determine if your content is working or if it needs a refresh, and when to decide your content needs professional help from the best content marketing agencies.

Common Questions You May Have

How do I know if my content is resonating with my audience?
What signs indicate it’s time to hire a content marketing agency?
What should I look for in a marketing agency to ensure they will meet my needs?

How would you score your content marketing? What rating would you give it today?

A significant portion of companies were not entirely satisfied with their content marketing efforts. 72% of marketers reported that their content marketing efforts ranged from unsuccessful to only moderately successful, according to a recent Impact Plus marketing study.

The next question is, what are you doing about it?

Every business knows content is king, yet many are missing the mark by underestimating what “good” content really is. Here’s how to determine if your content is working or if it needs a refresh, and when to decide your content needs professional help.

Understanding the Importance of Quality Content

Quality content is the backbone of any successful marketing strategy. It’s not just about filling up your blog with words; it’s about creating high-quality blogs that resonates with your target audience and drives meaningful engagement. High-quality content can help you establish your brand as an authority in your industry, build trust with your audience, and ultimately drive conversions. When your content is informative, well-researched, and tailored to your audience’s needs, it positions your brand as a go-to resource, fostering loyalty and credibility.

On the flip side, low-quality content can be detrimental. It can harm your brand’s reputation, leading to a loss of credibility and trust. Poorly written or irrelevant content can drive your audience away, resulting in decreased engagement and lower conversion rates. Therefore, investing in high-quality content is not just a good practice; it’s essential for the success of your content marketing efforts.

Is Your Content Cutting It?

Time to give yourself some honest (and possibly brutal) feedback. Here are five steps to determine if your content strategy is working.

Before you start, define Clear Objectives. Before diving into metrics, establish what you aim to achieve with your content. Are you trying to increase website traffic, generate leads, boost brand awareness, or all of the above? Clear goals will help you determine which metrics are most relevant. Incorporate lead generation strategies to ensure your content not only attracts but also converts visitors into leads.

Compile an Inventory of Content: List all your blog posts, videos, and other content pieces to see what you have available.
Evaluate Performance: Use tools like Google Analytics and SEMrush to assess traffic, engagement, bounce rates, and conversion metrics.
Identify Content Gaps: Look for topics your competitors cover that you don’t. Use tools like Ahrefs to find keywords and themes where you’re missing out.
Analyze SEO Data: Check keyword rankings, meta descriptions, and backlink profiles to spot areas for improvement.
Optimize Underperforming Content: Refresh and update older posts with new data, keywords, and insights to enhance their value.

Example: CoSchedule’s Content Audit Success

CoSchedule conducted a thorough content audit and discovered their top-performing content was often repurposed into various formats such as infographics, ebooks, and social media posts. This led to a significant increase in overall traffic and engagement by 72%.

How to Fix Your Content Marketing Strategy

It’s time to revamp your content marketing strategy to ensure it’s equipped for current and future challenges. Here are actionable tips and tools to get you started.

Consider leveraging professional content marketing services to develop tailored strategies that integrate traditional and digital marketing techniques.

Actionable Tips:

Adapt to Current SEO Trends: Stay up-to-date with SEO changes. For example, optimizing for e-commerce SEO by incorporating long-tail keywords and enhancing site speed can significantly impact your search rankings.

Shopify’s SEO Overhaul: Shopify conducted an in-depth SEO optimization and saw a 32% increase in organic traffic. By focusing on usability and keyword optimization, they appealed directly to user intent and search engine algorithms.

Refresh Your Website Copy: Hire a professional website copywriter to ensure your content is engaging, clear, and SEO-friendly. High-quality copy can lead to longer site visits and higher conversion rates.
SEO Content Writers: Consider hiring specialized SEO content writers to refine your content’s SEO aspects deeply. Their expertise can make sure your content is not only gripping but also ranks well in search engine results.

A structured approach to create content, including multiple quality checks and strategic keyword identification, can significantly enhance your content’s effectiveness.

Emerging Tools and Tactics

The digital marketing landscape evolves rapidly. Stay ahead by leveraging the latest tools and tactics.

Explore AI Writing Tools: AI-powered writing platforms like Jarvis and Copy.ai can assist in creating high-quality content quickly and efficiently.
Evaluate New Platforms: Investigate new platforms like TikTok, Clubhouse, or emerging content marketing agencies that can offer fresh avenues for reaching your audience.

AI has revolutionized content creation over the past few years. For instance, Jasper, formerly known as Jarvis, provides AI-assisted copywriting that helps businesses generate copy at scale with impressive human-like quality. Research by Gartner predicts that by 2025, AI will create nearly 30% of all content worldwide.

Signs You Need Help with Your Content Creation

If you see a consistent decline in traffic and engagement, it may be time to call for backup. Several telltale signs indicate that your current content strategy might need a professional upgrade:

Decreasing Organic Traffic: If your website’s organic traffic is stagnating or falling, it could indicate that your content isn’t resonating with your audience or is poorly optimized for search engines.
Low Engagement Rates: Pay attention to metrics such as time on page, bounce rates, and social media interactions. Low numbers here suggest your content does not captivate or engage your audience effectively, indicating a need for more engaging content.
Lack of Qualified Leads: If your content isn’t contributing to your lead generation efforts as expected, it may not be targeted appropriately or lack the depth necessary to convert readers into leads.

When to Consider Hiring a Professional Content Marketing Agency

Here are ten of the most common problems companies struggle with their content marketing strategy. Do you notice a theme? They are all related to content creation, which is not the company’s top priority. Nor should they be it. A content marketing company can help you develop a robust content strategy that aligns with your business goals and objectives. These are the areas a Marketing Agency can focus on for you.

Benefits of Working with a Content Marketing Agency

Partnering with a marketing agency can be a game-changer for businesses of all sizes. These agencies specialize in creating high-quality content that not only captures the attention of your target audience but also drives conversions. By working with a content marketing agency, you gain access to a team of experts who understand the nuances of creating engaging and compelling content.

A good content marketing agency aligns with your internal team’s workflow and culture over time. They will help you develop a robust content strategy that aligns with your business goals and objectives. They can conduct thorough market research to understand your audience’s preferences and pain points, ensuring that your content strategy aligns with their needs. This strategic approach can significantly enhance your online presence and boost your brand’s visibility.

Moreover, content marketing agencies bring a wealth of expertise and experience to the table. They are well-versed in the latest content marketing trends and techniques, ensuring that your content remains relevant and effective. Agencies offer a variety of content creation services including blogs, videos, newsletters, and social media content.

However, many businesses find it challenging to choose the right content marketing agency due to the abundance of options available. The best content marketing agencies will prioritize your company’s goals and produce results.

Professional agencies bring a wealth of expertise and precision that can be difficult to achieve in-house. Here are some of the key offerings:

Advanced SEO Techniques: A content agency is adept at implementing cutting-edge SEO strategies, including voice search optimization, structured data, and long-tail keyword research. Moz, for instance, witnessed a 33% increase in traffic through their voice search SEO campaign in 2025.
Content Strategy and Planning: Agencies can devise comprehensive content strategies that include detailed editorial calendars, audience personas, and content gap analysis.
High-Quality Content Creation: From blog posts to whitepapers, professional content marketers have a team of seasoned writers capable of creating compelling and informative content.
Data-Driven Insights: Agencies use sophisticated analytics tools to track performance, providing actionable insights and refining strategies to ensure continuous improvement.
Watch the Price: Working with a top-tier content marketing agency can be expensive, making budget management an important consideration.

Key Questions to Ask a Content Marketing Agency

Selecting the right content marketing agency involves asking the right questions to evaluate their fit with your brand value and business objectives. Here are the essential questions you should ask:

What is your experience in our industry?
Understanding the agency’s familiarity with your industry can give you confidence in their ability to create relevant and effective content.
Can you provide case studies?
What are their success stories? Ask for details similar to those HubSpot provided for their work with Suburban Hospital, which saw a 42% increase in online appointments. This transparency can show proof of their capabilities and success.
What strategies make our content stand out?
Inquire about their creative process to differentiating your content from competitors. Do they use unique insights, creative formats, or innovative distribution tactics?
How do you measure performance and ROI?
Knowing their metrics for success will give you an idea of how they track and optimize performance. How will they track your business growth and provide valuable insights? Metrics might include conversion rates, engagement stats, and lead generation.
What is the communication and approval process?
A clear communication protocol ensures that you stay informed and involved without micromanaging the agency. Do they communicate ideas clearly? Understanding their process helps set expectations for timelines and approvals.
How do you differentiate your services from other content marketing agencies?
Ask how they stand out in delivering results and enhancing client traffic value. Understanding their unique offerings and client-focused strategies can help you choose the right agency that aligns with your business goals.

After partnering with a content marketing agency, Airbnb saw a remarkable 300% increase in user-generated content. This approach not only boosted engagement but also built greater trust among their users. By leveraging user-generated content, Airbnb tapped into authentic experiences shared by their community, which can be more persuasive than traditional advertising.

The Future of Content Marketing Agencies

The future of content marketing agencies is promising, as the demand for high-quality content continues to rise. As businesses increasingly shift their focus to digital marketing, the role of content marketing agencies becomes even more critical. These agencies will continue to play a pivotal role in helping businesses create engaging and compelling content that resonates with their target audience.

With the advent of artificial intelligence and machine learning, content marketing agencies will need to adapt and evolve. These technologies offer new opportunities for creating high-quality content more efficiently and effectively. For instance, AI can assist in generating data-driven insights, optimizing content for search engines, and even automating certain aspects of content creation.

However, one thing remains constant: the importance of high-quality content. Regardless of technological advancements, high-quality content will always be the cornerstone of any successful content marketing strategy. Content marketing agencies that can leverage new technologies while maintaining a focus on quality will be well-positioned to thrive in the future.

In conclusion, content marketing agencies are poised to play an increasingly vital role in the digital marketing landscape. By staying ahead of the curve and continuing to prioritize high-quality content, these agencies can help businesses achieve their marketing goals and drive long-term success.

Conclusion

If content creation is not your thing, that’s ok. Hiring a professional content marketing agency can be a game-changer for businesses struggling to see meaningful results from their content efforts. Recognizing the signs that you need expert help and understanding what a professional agency brings to the table are crucial steps in making this important decision. Asking the right questions and examining successful case studies can further guide you in selecting the perfect partner to elevate your content strategy. Ultimately, with the right agency, your business can achieve increased engagement, enhanced lead generation, and a stronger presence in the digital landscape.

FAQ

How do I know if my content is resonating with my audience?

Check engagement metrics such as high time on page, low bounce rates, social media interactions, and positive feedback.

What signs indicate it’s time to hire a content marketing agency?

Consider hiring an agency if you see declining organic traffic, low engagement, poor lead generation, or lack of internal expertise.

What should I look for in a content marketing agency to ensure they will meet my needs?

Look for industry experience, successful case studies, clear performance metrics, effective communication, and a strategic approach.